Best MagicPost Alternative for Founders in 2025
MagicPost is solid if LinkedIn scheduling is your main thing. But here's the trade-off: €39/mo for 30 posts, LinkedIn only, no free tier. We charge $29 for unlimited, work on 3 platforms, and let you try 25 posts free before paying anything. Different priorities.
Why Users Switch from MagicPost to Tonemark
Learns YOUR writing style from samples - vocabulary, sentence structure, tone, personality
RAG-based generation with source citations for every claim
Facts Store + Style Store separation prevents contamination
Converts vague ideas to content angles - solves blank page problem
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
See how Tonemark and MagicPost compare across key features
| Feature | Tonemark$29/mo | MagicPost€39/mo (~$42) | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Voice Learning(Key) | Tonemark | ||
| Citation Transparency(Key) | Tonemark | ||
| Two-Track Knowledge Base(Key) | Tonemark | ||
| LinkedIn Posts | Tie | ||
| Blog Articles | Tonemark | ||
| Multi-Platform | Tonemark | ||
| Scheduling | Planned | MagicPost | |
| Analytics | Planned | MagicPost | |
| Trending Topics | Planned | Tonemark |
Pricing Comparison
- 100 generations/month
- Unlimited personas
- Learns your writing style
- Uses your facts, always cited
- Knowledge base grounding
Pro: €59/mo (~$64)
- Scheduling & mentions built-in
- Hooks generator and ideas generator
- LinkedIn metrics and engagement tracking
- Post inspirations library
- 5,000+ satisfied customers
Save 45% with Tonemark
That's $3913/month or $46956/year in savings
Common Questions About Switching
True. Their scheduling is more mature than ours. We do one-click publish, but if you need a full content calendar with time slots, MagicPost or Buffer might serve you better right now. We're focused on making the content itself better first.
They do. The difference: their hooks are templates everyone uses. Ours learn from YOUR past posts. Whether that matters depends on how much you care about sounding like yourself vs. sounding like a LinkedIn guru.
Yep, their analytics are decent. We don't have that yet. If tracking impressions and engagement per post is critical for you, MagicPost wins there. We bet on better content leading to better metrics, but we can't prove that for you—you'd have to test it.
They do. We're newer. If you want the safe choice with more users, go with them. If you want to try something different that might work better for your specific voice, we're worth a shot. The free tier means you risk nothing finding out.
Then MagicPost might be fine for you. Seriously. Our edge is multi-platform—if you're never touching X or Reddit, you're paying for features you won't use. Though our free tier is still more generous than their paid starter.
Frequently Asked Questions
Depends what you need. MagicPost is better if: you only use LinkedIn, you love their scheduling UI, or you want a tool with 5,000+ users behind it. Tonemark is better if: you post to multiple platforms, you're tired of AI content that sounds generic, or you want to try before paying (we have a free tier, they don't). Neither is objectively better—different tools for different workflows.
About 31% cheaper on paper. MagicPost Starter is €39/mo (~$42), Tonemark Pro is $29/mo. But the real difference is the free tier—we give you 25 posts/month free forever, no credit card. MagicPost charges from day one. If you're testing which tool works for you, that matters.
They have templates and a hooks generator, but it's not learning YOUR specific writing style. We analyze your past posts and try to match how YOU write—sentence length, vocabulary, tone. Is it perfect? No. But it's different from picking a template labeled 'Professional' or 'Casual'. Whether that difference matters is up to you.
Not as well, honestly. We have one-click publish, but MagicPost has a fuller scheduling system with calendar views. If scheduling is your #1 priority, they're ahead there. We're building Content Series (automated posting) but it's not live yet. Right now we're focused on making the content better—scheduling is secondary for us.
Yes—LinkedIn, X/Twitter, and Reddit. Each with platform-specific formatting (thread splitting for X, anti-promotional tone for Reddit, etc.). MagicPost is LinkedIn-only. If you're a LinkedIn purist, that's fine. If you want to repurpose content across platforms without switching tools, that's where we're useful.
Yes. Upload your docs, product pages, whatever—and we pull facts from them when generating content, with citations showing which file each claim came from. MagicPost doesn't have this. It matters if you're writing about your product and want accuracy. It matters less if you're posting personal opinions.
Other Comparisons
Try Tonemark Free Today
Upload your writing samples, add your knowledge base, and generate your first authentic post in minutes. No credit card required.
Save 45% vs MagicPost